A conversation with Jennifer Knight, co-director of DevelopMe Northwest CIC
Learning transfer in first aid training is one of the hardest challenges in the sector. People leave with a certificate and rarely use what they learned, until the moment it matters most.
We spoke with Jennifer about the challenges of learning transfer in high-stakes
training, how she’s tackling retention after the course ends, and what she thinks the
wider training industry needs to pay more attention to.
The Problem With Tick-Box Training
First aid sits in an uncomfortable position in the training market. For most
organisations, it’s a legal requirement which means some learners arrive already
disengaged.
“A lot of what we’re up against is that people do it because they have to. They turn up so
they can say they’ve got the certificate.”
Jennifer is candid about the consequences. When she asks repeat delegates whether
they remember what they covered last time, the answer is frequently no. And for
most of them, that’s not surprising: the chances of needing to treat a burn or perform
CPR in a typical office setting are genuinely low. Low frequency of use means the
knowledge doesn’t stay and practical skill fade is a constant challenge, even for the
most experienced medical professional.
Jennifer’s background gives her a different lens on this problem. Before moving into
training, she qualified as a teacher. And in formal education, you never teach
something once and move on.
“For me, I’m used to doing six-week or twelve-week lesson planning where we learn a point
here and come back to it here and there. To be like ‘well, I’ve taught you’ and that’s it — it’s
quite an odd concept.”
How Spaced Repetition Tackles Learning Transfer in First Aid
Jennifer’s response to this challenge is practical. DevelopMe is integrating monthly
follow-up questions into their post-course process, structured around spaced
repetition, the principle that revisiting information at intervals is what moves
knowledge from short-term to long-term memory.
The plan is to send course delegates a short set of questions once a month for the first
year after training, covering different topics depending on which course they
attended. As an example, a delegate who completed the Emergency First Aid at Work
course might receive questions on CPR one month, burns the next, then choking.
“If we have somebody who asks you on a regular basis, then hopefully it’ll stick because
that was part of what Paul said. It’s the going over it again and again that makes you
remember it. If you do it once and never look at it again, it just leaves your head.”
The aim isn’t to test people. It’s to keep the information active, so that if a real
emergency does happen, the training is accessible rather than buried under two years
of unrelated experience.
Performing Under Pressure
There’s a layer to first aid retention that doesn’t apply to most training subjects. It’s
not enough for a delegate to remember the steps, they need to be able to access that
knowledge in a high-stress moment when panic is working against them.
“What will happen is you will panic. That voice in your head will go: ‘Oh my god, I don’t
know what to do.’ All I’m trying to do today is give you just a second to pause and go:
actually, Jennifer told me — I do know what I’m doing.”
This is why Jennifer’s approach to the classroom itself matters as much as what
happens after it. She introduced more interactive, activity-based learning when she
joined DevelopMe, back when it was its predecessor HBA Training, replacing the
‘chalk and talk’ style that many subject-matter experts default to. Building familiarity
with procedures in a low-stakes, realistic environment is what makes them more
retrievable when it counts.
Measuring impact
Like many training providers, in the past DevelopMe relied on feedback forms at the
end of a course. Jennifer is honest that this doesn’t tell her much about what actually
happened to the learning.
“Someone pays us an amount and then at the end of the day, that’s it. There’s no follow-up.
There’s no ‘so what did you learn that we should do differently?’”
She describes the friction this creates: she tells delegates during the course what they
need to check when they return to their workplace first aid kits, accident books,
hazardous waste bags and then never follows up to find out whether they actually did
it. This is not something that is unique to Jennifer or her company, but rather
something that occurs across the industry as a whole. It is Jennifer’s background in
teaching that means that this is something that doesn’t sit right with her.
What happens in the training room and what changes in the real world is a gap that
spaced repetition helps close, but only partially. Follow-through, manager support,
and measurement all play a role too.
What the Research Says About Managers
One of the insights Jennifer found most striking was around the role managers play
in whether training sticks, not just their attitude toward learning, but the active
support structures they build around it.
Several researchers, e.g. Ina Weinbauer-Heidel and Masha Ibeschitz-Manderbach,
suggest that the line manager is the single biggest influencer on whether training
transfers into changed behaviour.
For first aid, this might look like a manager who asks a returning delegate to brief the
rest of the team on what they learned, or who refers back to the training in team
meetings, or who checks that the health and safety actions the delegate committed to
have actually been completed. Small things, consistently done, that keep the learning
active.
Convincing People Who Don’t Have To
Beyond improving retention for mandated training, Jennifer faces a harder
commercial challenge: persuading people who have no legal requirement to do a first
aid course that they should do one anyway.
Her most compelling case is to self-employed professionals; hairdressers, beauty
therapists, sole traders who work with clients and chemicals, often alone. The
question she asks them is simple: what would you actually do if there was an
emergency and you were the only person in the room?
The answer she wants to avoid is framing it in terms of risk. The consequence of not
doing first aid training can, in extreme cases, be fatal but leading with that message
creates anxiety rather than motivation. The more effective frame is capability:
knowing what to do in the moment gives you confidence, and it gives your clients
reassurance that they’re in good hands.
About Jennifer Knight
Jennifer Knight is co-director of DevelopMe Northwest CIC, a first aid and health and safety training company based in Merseyside, previously HBA Training. With a background in formal education, Jennifer brings a pedagogical approach to a sector where most trainers come from operational backgrounds. DevelopMe works with GP surgeries, schools, businesses, and individuals across the north west region.





